The statue of former Supreme Court Chief Justice Roger B. Taney was removed from the Maryland State House in August 2017, ending its 145-year presence outside the capital building.

Roger Taney’s Legacy

Grade 9-12

On August 18, 2017, Maryland officials removed the statue of Roger B. Taney that had stood outside the Maryland State House in Annapolis. Taney, a Maryland native and former Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, is best known for authoring the Court’s decision in Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), which ruled that African Americans were not citizens of the United States. The statue was erected in 1872 during the Reconstruction era. Today, the statue is in the care of the Maryland State Archives.

In this lesson, students will examine the legacy of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney and the Dred Scott decision to explore the debate surrounding his 2017 statue removal and consider how societies decide which historical figures to honor with public monuments.

Teacher's Guide and Related Standards

Lesson Objective

Students will analyze the legacy of Roger B. Taney.

Essential Questions

  • How did Roger B. Taney and the decision in Dred Scott v. Sandford affect American society?
  • How did contemporaries view Taney when his statue was erected at the Maryland State House in 1872?
  • Should Taney’s statue have been removed from the Maryland State House in 2017?

Video Clip


 


Thinking questions:

  • How should societies decide which historical figures are honored with public monuments?
  • How can studying controversial figures help us better understand the history and development of the United States?


Vocabulary


Supplemental Enrichment Activities

Enrichment Activity 1

Analyzing the Dred Scott Decision

To better understand the impact of the Dred Scott decision on American society, students will read historian David W. Blight’s discussion on the  PBS: Africans in America website.

Using information from the reading, students will write a brief constructed response answering the question: How did Roger B. Taney’s decision in Dred Scott v. Sandfordaffect American society? Provide students with a notecatcher to organize their thoughts and evidence.

Enrichment Activity 2

Examining Public Reaction

Students will examine public reaction to the unveiling of Taney’s statue in 1872 by reading a newspaper article titled "The Taney Unveiling Ceremonies," to learn more about his role in the war and connection to Washington.

While reading, students should highlight words and phrases that reveal the author's point of view. Students should also consider how the author describes Taney and his statue, the historical context surrounding these statements, and the text's overall purpose and intended audience.

Enrichment Activity 3

Debating Monument Removal

Students will make a claim in response to the essential question: Should Taney’s statue have been removed from the Maryland State House in 2017? They must support their claim with specific evidence.

Extend the learning and organize students to participate in an organized class debate on the topic. The debate can be structured using this Debate Format .


Career Connections