Home — A Nation Begins: The Maryland State House at 250 — Lesson Starters — Political Division, Past and Present — Teacher's Guide
Aerial view of Annapolis, Md., in the mid-19th century.
Political Division, Past and Present
Grade 8
Teacher’s Guide and Related Standards
In this lesson, students will examine historical examples of political division to explore the causes and impacts of conflict, connecting these themes to the modern world and how political division has shaped democratic ideals in the United States.
Procedure
Students will explore how political division shapes democratic ideals through class discussions, contemporary connections, and video analysis. Their task will be to craft a Claim, Evidence, Reasoning (CER) response using lesson resources to evaluate the impact of political conflict. Final reflection prompts on navigating disagreement and finding common ground are also included.
INTRODUCTION (20 minutes)
- To connect to prior learning, teachers may ask students to discuss and provide examples of political divisions during the American Revolution, as covered in elementary school. Students can also make connections to today’s world by having students share examples of political division from today’s society.
- Explain that students will be learning about historical examples of U.S. political division to determine how conflict, compromise, and civic engagement have shaped democratic ideals over time. Play the video clip.
- As a class, discuss the lesson’s essential question and the thinking questions. This could be done via a whole-group discussion, such as a Socratic Seminar or using a think-pair-share format.
EXTENSION (30 - 120 minutes)
Complete the three supplemental enrichment activities with students, as you see fit.
SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT (30-40 minutes)
- Have students apply their newfound knowledge from the lesson by completing a summative Claim, Evidence, Reasoning (CER) paper that answers the following essential question: How has political division shaped democratic ideals in the United States?
- Students can use the sources in the "Research Support" section to investigate the topic.
- To support their claim, students should use evidence from at least two historical examples and the A Nation Begins: The Maryland State House at 250 video clip to explain how political conflict can either strengthen or weaken democracy over time.
- Refer to the following rubric.
REFLECTION (10 minutes)
Have students complete a reflection in response to the following questions.
- What part of this lesson connected with you most? Why?
- How does this new knowledge connect to something you already know or believe?
- How do you handle interacting with peers who completely disagree with you?
- How is it possible to find middle ground in order to work toward democratic ideals?
CER Rubric (Total: 9 Points)
|
|
3 Points
|
2 Points
|
1 Point |
0 Points
|
| Claim |
The student clearly answered the question chosen. The claim fully addresses the topic. |
The student answered the question, but the claim may be somewhat unclear or incomplete. |
The claim is unclear, too general, or does not fully answer the question. |
No claim |
| Evidence |
The student used specific, accurate facts from the lesson activities. |
The student used some evidence, but it may be general, lack detail, or need more explanation. |
The student gave limited, weak, or unclear evidence. |
No evidence |
| Reasoning |
The student clearly explained how the evidence supports the claim. |
The student explained their thinking, but the connection between the evidence and the claim is not fully clear. |
The student’s reasoning was unclear, incomplete, and largely repeated the evidence. |
No evidence |
Standards
C3 and Maryland Standards
Maryland Social Studies Standards
Standard 2.0 Peoples of the Nations and World
- Students shall inquire about the people of the United States and the world using a historically grounded, multidisciplinary approach in order to recognize multiple narratives and acknowledge the diversity and commonality of the human experience.
Standard 5.0 History
- Students shall inquire about significant events, ideas, beliefs, and themes to identify patterns and trends and to analyze how individuals and societies have changed over time to make connections to the present in their communities, Maryland, the United States, and the world.
Standard 6.0 Skills and Processes
- Students shall inquire about civics, geography, economics, history, and people and nations of the world using disciplinary literacy skills and processes to critically evaluate content through a variety of source materials across disciplines and use reading, writing, and other forms of communication to develop, defend, and critique arguments in order to take informed action.
-
D2.His.1.6-8. Analyze connections among events and developments in broader historical contexts.
- D2.His.2.6-8. Classify series of historical events and developments as examples of change and/or continuity.
- D2.His.3.6-8. Use questions generated about individuals and groups to analyze why they, and the developments they shaped, are seen as historically significant.
- D2.His.4.6-8. Analyze multiple factors that influenced the perspectives of people during different historical eras.
References
PBS, A Nation Begins: The Maryland State House at 250 - A film clip from A Nation Begins: The Maryland State House at 250 was used in this lesson. Continue to watch the full documentary to learn about the oldest state capitol in continuous legislative use—and the only one to ever serve as the capital of the United States.